Content on Jalopnik Advisor is commercial in nature and independent of Jalopnik Editorial and Advertising. Jalopnik Advisor content is free to consumers and always will be, however we and our partners may be compensated if you purchase a product or service through the links on this website.

Best All-Season Tires Review

Our team takes an in-depth look at the best all-season tires on the market.
03/20/2023 03:45 AM

While your new car will come with brand-new tires, they’ll eventually need to be replaced. If you live in an area with all four seasons, you’ll need tires that can handle diverse driving conditions. Our expert team has researched and reviewed the best all-season tires in the industry to help you find the set of tires that’s right for your vehicle.

Whether you’re driving in winter weather, wet conditions, or summer heat, the best all-season tires can handle it all. Our expert review team breaks down what separates all-season tires from other types of tires, such as summer tires or winter tires, as well as average costs so you know what to expect.

What Are All-Season Tires?

All-season tires offer versatile performance in a variety of weather conditions. Featuring tread patterns and rubber compounds built for winter conditions, wet conditions, and more, these types of tires are equipped to handle many driving conditions for a safer experience on the road.

Though the term “all-season tires” may give drivers the impression that these tires are adept in all weather conditions, this is not the case. All-season tires are not suitable replacements for snow-specific tires, as they don’t have the snow traction necessary in deep snow. However, most all-season tires should be suitable for light snow and mild winter conditions.

Benefits Of All-Season Tires

Various benefits justify the cost of all-season tires, including:

  • Year-round performance in a variety of road conditions, from wet roads to driving off-road
  • Long tread life and higher durability than tires designed for specific weather conditions
  • Less treadwear and rolling resistance than snow tires designed for winter driving, meaning better fuel efficiency
  • Suitable for a variety of vehicles, including sedans and SUVs
  • Offer a comfortable and quiet ride due to the tread design and tread compound
  • Typically feature sipes, which improve cornering, offer better traction, and reduce the risk of hydroplaning
How to read a tire's sidewall

5 Best All-Season Tires

The best all-season tires offer ultra-high performance in a variety of driving scenarios. Our experts have done the research for you to provide our top five recommendations for the best all-season tires. These are some of the most popular all-season tires on Tire Rack, and we’ve included each model’s customer rating from the site:

All-Season Tire ModelTire Rack Customer Rating
#1 Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 ZP4.52 / 5.0
#2 Yokohama Avid Touring-S3.86 / 5.0
#3 Firestone All Season3.18 / 5.0
#4 Toyo NanoEnergy A293.62 / 5.0
#5 Yokohama Avid S34PV4.03 / 5.0

#1 Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 ZP

The Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 ZP is a run-flat tire built for year-round use. The “ZP” in the name stands for zero pressure, as this tire is built to withstand complete loss of pressure for a distance of 50 miles up to 50 mph. This all-season tire features Michelin’s Helio Compound™ technology, using sunflower oil to formulate a sustainable and biodegradable material that helps tread maintain flexibility in lower temperatures.

#2 Yokohama Avid Touring-S

Designed for smooth handling, ride quality, durability, and traction in any weather conditions, the Yokohama Avid Touring-S is a great all-season tire. No matter the season, traction is ensured through Yokohama’s Tri-Plex tread compound. The tire’s internal structure consists of two steel belts reinforced by nylon belt edge strips for better absorption of bumps and road vibrations.

#3 Firestone All Season

Developed for various types of vehicles, the Firestone All Season tire was made with drivers of coupes, sedans, and minivans in mind. Depending on the tire size, the Firestone All Season’s internal structure includes a one- or two-ply polyester body casing beneath two wide steel belts for stability and durability. This tire features a silica-enhanced tread compound formed into a symmetric design to promote even wear.

#4 Toyo NanoEnergy A29

This all-season tire is designed for drivers who want a smooth ride, good wear, and traction in any weather conditions. The Toyo NanoEnergry A29 features silica polymer dispersed throughout the compound for excellent grip in wet conditions and for decreased rolling resistance. This tire was specially developed with fuel economy and environmental impact in mind.

#5 Yokohama Avid S34PV

Featuring a tread design with staggered blocks and wide lateral grooves that resist hydroplaning, the Yokohama Avid S34PV maintains traction through both dry and wet conditions. The staggered tread blocks resist distortion, while the tread compound in the all-season tire reduces rolling resistance. Additionally, the tire’s multi-pitch design offers a quiet ride by limiting road noise.

Cost Of All-Season Tires

All-season tires cost about $84–$570, according to Tire Rack. Every tire model offers different  benefits, and each model’s price varies based on several common factors. The following items affect the cost of all-season tires, as well as prices for tires in general:

  • Tire size: Larger tires cost more than smaller ones, so a 20-inch tire will be more expensive than a 15-inch tire.
  • Tire brand: Some tire manufacturers invest more money in research and development of their products, which results in higher costs.
  • Type of tire: You’ll pay less for an economy tire than an ultra-high-performance tire.
  • Raw materials: The cost of the materials needed to make tires can fluctuate, which affects the cost of tires.

The number of options can be overwhelming when you’re searching for the best all-season tires, so it’s good to know which tire brands to start with. Below are our review team’s three highest-rated tire brands.

Michelin: Best Overall

Recognized as Best Overall in our 2022 review of tire brands, Michelin offers a variety of types of tires, including all-season tires. The brand separates itself from the competition through its dedication to tire innovation. Additionally, Michelin ranked highest in the passenger car segment in the J.D. Power 2021 U.S. Original Equipment Tire Customer Satisfaction Survey℠ with a score of 752 out of 1,000 points.

Learn more about the tire brand by reading our full Michelin tires review.

Goodyear: Most Durable

An American tire manufacturer founded in 1898 in Akron, Ohio, Goodyear provides high-quality tires. Goodyear was awarded an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and earned second place in the passenger car category in the latest J.D. Power Original Equipment Tire Customer Satisfaction Survey. Our review team also gave Goodyear the title of Most Durable in 2022.

Get a closer look at the company in our Goodyear tires review.

Cooper: Best Value

Cooper Tire & Rubber Co. is a subsidiary of Goodyear, but that doesn’t mean the two brands are the same. Our team of experts recognized Cooper as Best Value in our review of the top tire manufacturers. Cooper is the fifth-largest tire brand in North America and the 13th-largest in the world.

Check out our complete Cooper tires review for more information on the company,

Frequently Asked Questions

What tire brand is the best for all seasons?

The top two highest-rated all-season tires are the Yokohama AVID S34PV and the Yokohama AVID S34NV, according to Tire Rack. Therefore, our expert team concludes that Yokohama is the tire brand that’s best for all-season tires.

Who makes an all-weather tire?

Most notable tire brands make all-weather or all-season tires. Tire brands such as Pirelli, Hankook, Vredestein, Continental, Michelin, Goodyear, Firestone, and Yokohama make all-weather tires. Some of the best all-season tires are the Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 ZP and the Yokohama Avid Touring-S.

Are all-season tires OK for winter?

Yes, all-season tires will work for winter, though they’re designed for more mild temperature changes. However, winter tires are best for winter driving conditions.

How We Rate Tire Brands

Our review process aims to deliver consistent and unbiased assessments of tire brands. While there are multiple qualities that make a tire manufacturer successful, our review team focuses on those we believe are the most important for consumers:

  • Price: Tire size and type can both affect the final cost. Our team of experts compares pricing across a variety of tires from each brand.
  • Tire Variety: To determine this score, we look at the types of tires available, including passenger tires and light truck/SUV tires. Tire types can be based on the season, terrain, and other factors.
  • Reputation: The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) created the Uniform Tire Quality Grading (UTQG) Standards to score treadwear, traction, and temperature. Tire brands with high UTQG ratings perform best in this category. Established companies with a long history of reliable service also receive positive marks.
  • Customer Satisfaction: We comb through customer reviews on sites like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to learn about customer experiences. Tire brands with a low volume of complaints score well in this area. We also consider studies from experts like J.D. Power, giving top marks to companies that have a high customer satisfaction index.

*Data accurate at time of publication.